I am in the market and thought I would post a thread for opinion/insight.

Primary Use: Home Defense
Secondary Use: Range Fun

Emphasis on (in no specific order):

Reliability
Accurracy
Size
Weight
Quality/Engineering

For reliability a pump action seems to be the way to go, however a semi-auto really appeals to my handgun roots. (would also like the option of adding a rifled barrell as well as a pistol style grip for kicks/novelty)

I am not brand picky and cost is a consideration however I am willing to pay more for something I am happy with and not feel like I skimped on. Like everyone I am looking for a deal but am not shy away from spending money on higher end equipment. I do not hunt.

Looking forward to your personal picks & thoughts on this.