must a person provide ID while in any vehicle if stopped by a peace officer?

[gunperson003]

I'm curious, does a person have to identify if they're in any vehicle if they're not doing anything wrong? My question related to the use of roller blades.

Also, does anyone happen to know if the use of roller blades in the city of Pittsburgh is legal and where(street or sidewalks)?

[gunperson003]

Well, blading is legal in the streets, but not the sidewalk. I find it even more humorous for pittsburgh police to say, "*cough* people skate all the time on the sidewalks, even if someone complains the person is usually gone by the time we get there." ^_^ I think I love Pittsburgh LE, I've concluded they're wonderful people since I've been speaking with them on various questions.

[unix_slayer]

I thought the laws state you have to supply I'd when asked by a peace officer. Otherwise they could site [consider] you for loitering, or pandering.

[Emptymag]

Roller blades? A friggin' VEHICLE? Roller blades?


Lord, give me strength...

[gunperson003]

I thought the laws state you have to supply I'd when asked by a peace officer. Otherwise they could site [consider] you for loitering, or pandering.

They've no right to see any ID if you're not doing anything wrong.

I'm not sure about PA, but here in AK you don't have to carry ID unless you're driving.

[gnbrotz]

There is no legal requirement to present "paper ID" if you are not participating in a privileged activity (driving, hunting, concealing a firearm).

Rollerblading is not a 'privileged' activity, thus you do not need to present ID. An example - if you would steal a little old lady's purse while doing rollerblading, you may certainly be detained and even arrested for doing so. You would still have absolutely no legal obligation to possess or present a gov't issued ID.

[gnbrotz]

I thought the laws state you have to supply I'd when asked by a peace officer. Otherwise they could site [consider] you for loitering, or pandering.

I'm curious what info you've based this on?

[XD45]

I thought the laws state you have to supply I'd when asked by a peace officer. Otherwise they could site [consider] you for loitering, or pandering.

what does loitering or pandering have to do with showing ID?

I sure hope your not PSP.......

[jofreder]

There is no legal requirement to present "paper ID" if you are not participating in a privileged activity (driving, hunting, concealing a firearm).

If I am CC and a cop demands my LTCF, I need to provide it? Or does he need RAS to detain me and demand My LTCF.

[unix_slayer]

I'm curious what info you've based this on?

In most states in the Union, they would consider you a vagabond, or drifter without possessing a wallet without I'd.