Results 1 to 10 of 21
Thread: Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
-
August 13th, 2007, 12:16 AM #1Senior Member
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
-
Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania
(Philadelphia County) - Age
- 50
- Posts
- 362
- Rep Power
- 186
Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
Just doing some thinking about the 2nd Amendment and I came to a realization.
Why IS it second?
We live and die by the statement "The Second Amendment makes all the others possible". I wonder why the Founders chose fit to put it second if it is the most important?
The only reason I came up with was that the Founders probably had ready access to firearms but were facing an onslaught of infringements such as not being allowed to peaceably assemble, not being allowed to run "unauthorized" press, being arrested for non-violent public speech, facing religious persecution, and being denied the right to petition (All of which, as you know, are now protected [not granted!] by the First Amendment).
I have heard that our beautiful, beloved Constitution is a snapshot of the time that those Men and Women lived in. Notice the 3rd Amendment (no quartering of Federal troops without the Owner's consent). This is not even on our radar as a threat (when was the last time you sweated the FBI or the 10th Mountain drinking your beer?), but was apparantly such a nuisance that it is part of our Bill of Rights! That is the only reason that I can come up with that may place the 2nd amendment second....that the threats now protected against by the 1A were the most predominant in their lives, and that they were armed men.
In a former life I was on track to teach military history at the University level. That was long ago and pipe dreams away.... now I am in school for the medical field. This means I don't get to read as much history as I want (gotta study icky stuff instead.) Only recently have I begun to study our own Revolution (my time was spent studying the Cold War and the Vietnam War) simply out of interest as well as my impressions upon transplantation to the East Coast (and to Philly, where it all started!).
I googled my question, and, as usual, found it was like drinking from a firehose. SO I ask you all, what are the facts that you have? I know several of you are far more versed on these incredible men than I, so I want to hear what you have learned. Gimme references if you can, and lots of knowledge, please.
Thanks!NEED should never enter into a discussion about RIGHTS
-
August 13th, 2007, 12:22 AM #2
-
August 13th, 2007, 08:32 AM #3
Re: Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
I'm slogging through the Federalist Papers now hoping to find some insight into the mindset of the authors of the U.S. Constitution.
Keep a dictionary at hand if you intend to read these documents, preferably Noah Webster’s 1828 American Dictionary, which I believe will give the closest definition to the original language intended.Veritas Vos Liberat
-
August 13th, 2007, 10:38 AM #4
Re: Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
glad to see I was not the only one who was having issues with the Federalist Papers.....
Now from my rusty and not so trusty brain case I seem to recall that there was some debate on the 2nd amendment being listed first, but it was made 2nd because of some hope that an educated republic is the first and best defense of freedom and if that should fail then the only choice remaining was to take up arms.
The framers were a truly optomistic bunch and they had high hopes for this repbulic and the industry of its people.
Its a shame we are slowy becoming the 'navel starers' our founders scoffed their former masters for being........
This is just a faint and dim memory from a class I had back in the last millenium and as such may be inaccurate, out of date or just plain damn wrong. The poster assumes no liability for the accuracy or verasity of this post.......... j/k
And from that same course what I recall from the same course the 3rd amenment came from the fine Brit and Torry custom of taking a homestead over and for sport killing the occupants.....makes rugby look tame don't it? j/k
Hope this helps
-
August 13th, 2007, 11:02 PM #5Grand Member
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
-
Pennsyltucky,
Pennsylvania
- Posts
- 8,076
- Rep Power
- 21474862
Re: Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
Just my opinion, but without the 1st the second would be moot.
FUCK BIDEN
-
August 13th, 2007, 11:06 PM #6Senior Member
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
-
Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania
(Philadelphia County) - Age
- 50
- Posts
- 362
- Rep Power
- 186
-
August 13th, 2007, 11:19 PM #7
Re: Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
The right to voice your opposition to the tyrrany seems to naturally precede taking up arms. Basically tell those in power that you don't approve and if they don't listen to the masses, show them that you do not approve. Just my $.02
When the government has a knife at your throat and a hand on your wallet, it matters not whether it is the left or the right hand.
-
August 13th, 2007, 11:44 PM #8Grand Member
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
-
Pennsyltucky,
Pennsylvania
- Posts
- 8,076
- Rep Power
- 21474862
Re: Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
Nothing terribly enigmatic. Just that if our right to free speech and assembly were considered less important than RTKBA I suspect that we wouldn’t miss our 2A rights
because it wouldn’t exist, or the Bill of Rights, for that matter. I feel the Constitution must be viewed as bricks and mortar that stand strong together. None necessarily more important than the other, but if weakened individually, could cause the collapse of a truly ingenious society. One, which I fear, is in danger of just that. All Americans may have particular aspects of the Constitution that they feel “closer” to than others, but it’s the totality of it’s meaning that is great, not just one aspect or another.FUCK BIDEN
-
August 13th, 2007, 11:48 PM #9Grand Member
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
-
Pennsyltucky,
Pennsylvania
- Posts
- 8,076
- Rep Power
- 21474862
-
August 14th, 2007, 12:55 AM #10
Re: Why is the 2nd Amendment 2nd?
I'd say pretty much what everyone else has. Need the first to even know the 2nd exists. Knowledge is power...the first makes sure that the government does not keep it from us.
Similar Threads
-
THE UNABRIDGED 2ND AMENDMENT
By LastManOut in forum GeneralReplies: 5Last Post: August 9th, 2007, 11:23 AM -
First Amendment
By Vtwin_Guy in forum GeneralReplies: 34Last Post: April 15th, 2007, 09:16 PM -
2nd Amendment Rally 4-24-07
By soberbyker in forum GeneralReplies: 0Last Post: April 14th, 2007, 06:48 PM -
2nd Amendment case being heard now
By LittleRedToyota in forum GeneralReplies: 19Last Post: January 27th, 2007, 03:00 PM -
Scope of 2nd Amendment Questioned
By phillyd2 in forum GeneralReplies: 18Last Post: December 13th, 2006, 01:24 AM
Bookmarks