I'm feeling like a new plinker. Went to my preferred local funshop to compare the Sig with the S&W. Unfortunately they didn't have the Sig and weren't terribly optimistic about how soon they'd be getting it. They did have the S&W in stock though.

I'm a Sigaholic so I went in there a bit biased. I must say though that the S&W was impressive and despite all of the internet ramblings about plastic parts it felt solid and well-made. I'd certainly have no problem owning one.

Has anyone had the chance to compare both of these rifles, I'd love to hear some observations. It's certainly not a life-altering decision; I'm sure I'd be very happy with either but I like to be an educated consumer.

Thanks