Virgin Islands Allows National Guard To Seize Guns, Ammo Ahead Of Hurricane Irma

[Bang]

Gov acknowledged in Tucker Carlton interview that federal law precludes the seizing of civilian arms and ammo (like the gov of Louisiana did after Katrina) and emphasized the law is designed to accommodate military needs that can be met at marketing sources.

However, Prohibit the sale, exchange, loan or donation, during the emergency of arms, ammunition, explosives, gasoline, incendiary material or alcoholic beverages, and the closing of any establishment in which any such property is found. certainly is designed to curtail civilian acquisition should things go south and those in need of these items are as screwed as Katrina residents were.

[scruff]

Gov acknowledged in Tucker Carlton interview that federal law precludes the seizing of civilian arms and ammo (like the gov of Louisiana did after Katrina) and emphasized the law is designed to accommodate military needs that can be met at marketing sources.

However, Prohibit the sale, exchange, loan or donation, during the emergency of arms, ammunition, explosives, gasoline, incendiary material or alcoholic beverages, and the closing of any establishment in which any such property is found. certainly is designed to curtail civilian acquisition should things go south and those in need of these items are as screwed as Katrina residents were.

AFAIK, he didn't implement that part of the law. It's not in the order that's linked earlier here.

[allenr]

It is not so simple as the Daily Caller reported. The wording of the emergency order is reported at Breitbart News as follows:

"The order says:

The Adjutant General is directed pursuant to Title 23, Section 1520, Virgin Islands Code to take whatever actions she considers necessary to carry out the assigned mission. In accordance with Title 23 Section 1522, Virgin Islands Code, The Adjutant General is authorized and directed to seize arms, ammunition, explosives, incendiary material and any other property that may be required by the military forces for the performance of this emergency mission, in accordance with the Rules of Force promulgated by the Virgins Island National Guard and approved by the Virgin Islands Department of Justice."

That is not a violation of a Constitututional right. In that it does not order the seizure of anything without the approval of the Justice Department of VI. If such an authorized seizure were to occur as part of the emergency, it would be an illegal search and seizure because there would be no means of due process due to the emergency. The only protection is the judgement of the Justice Department whose duty it is to apply the law.

The same thing could happen in any US state, but it would be very unlikely. What distinguishes the VI is that it's Natioanl Guard unit is not well equipped and supplied. In the event of hurricane caused rioting, looting, etc. the NG might just need civilian assets to perform its duties. NG units are funded to a great extent by the state or territory. While the VI sees many wealthy visitors, it is not itself a wealthy place.

[allenr]

Hurricane Irma has passed over the Virgin Islands and moved on. For those who were worried about having guns and ammo seized the fact is that the VI government did not seize anyone's guns, ammo, or other property. Precautionary s are not predictions.

[allenr]

Why would the National Guard need those items to respond? Aren't they already stocked with those items?

Oo
Being very familiar with the US VI I can tell you that the NG is not well stocked on such items. Territory budgets cannot cover the costs and the US does not.

[scruff]

Jeesh, Dana Loesch and Tucker are squawking away again about this nothingburger. It would be nice if they came back with some facts.

[Krichardson]

Jeesh, Dana Loesch and Tucker are squawking away again about this nothingburger. It would be nice if they came back with some facts.

I caught that too.

[sgmwatkins]

Hi all,

So this was an article posted on US LawShield's blog:

During the recent disaster wrought by Hurricane Harvey in Texas and the impending landfall in Florida of Hurricane Irma, many of our members have been asking if the government can confiscate their firearms if the Governor or Federal Government declare a state of emergency.

Following the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina in 2005, the New Orleans police went door to door seeking people who rode out the storm in their homes to force them to comply with the forced evacuation ordered by the government. As part of the effort, the officers were also confiscating firearms.

This created an outrage among the law-abiding gun owners of the country and resulted in the passage of state and federal laws to prevent such confiscations from occurring in the future.

In 2006, Congress passed the DISASTER RECOVERY PERSONAL PROTECTION ACT OF 2006. The law was intended to prevent the government from seizing legally owned firearms during the time of a disaster. It was incorporated as an amendment to the Department of Homeland Security Appropriations Act 2007 and signed into law on October 4, 2006.
CAN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT CONFISCATE MY FIREARMS?

This law amended 42 U.S.C 5201 Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act to add the following provision:

SEC. 706. FIREARMS POLICIES.

(a) PROHIBITION ON CONFISCATION OF FIREARMS- No officer or employee of the United States (including any member of the uniformed services), or person operating pursuant to or under color of Federal law, or receiving Federal funds, or under control of any Federal official, or providing services to such an officer, employee, or other person, while acting in support of relief from a major disaster or emergency, may–

(1) temporarily or permanently seize, or authorize seizure of, any firearm the possession of which is not prohibited under Federal, State, or local law, other than for forfeiture in compliance with Federal law or as evidence in a criminal investigation;

(2) require registration of any firearm for which registration is not required by Federal, State, or local law;

(3) prohibit possession of any firearm, or promulgate any rule, regulation, or order prohibiting possession of any firearm, in any place or by any person where such possession is not otherwise prohibited by Federal, State, or local law; or

(4) prohibit the carrying of firearms by any person otherwise authorized to carry firearms under Federal, State, or local law, solely because such person is operating under the direction, control, or supervision of a Federal agency in support of relief from the major disaster or emergency.

(b) LIMITATION- Nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit any person in subsection (a) from requiring the temporary surrender of a firearm as a condition for entry into any mode of transportation used for rescue or evacuation during a major disaster or emergency, provided that such temporarily surrendered firearm is returned at the completion of such rescue or evacuation.

Following the lead of the federal government, most state legislatures adopted their own version of this law.
TEXAS LAW ON FIREARMS CONFISCATION

In Texas, Government Code Chapter 418 (EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT) permits the Governor to declare a State of Disaster which suspends certain state laws and regulations to allow local authorities to conduct rescue and recovery operations.

However, it does not allow for the seizure of any legally owned firearms, with limited exception.

Specifically,

Sec. 418.003. LIMITATIONS. This chapter does not:

(5) except as provided by Section 418.184, authorize the seizure or confiscation of any firearm or ammunition from an individual who is lawfully carrying or possessing the firearm or ammunition;

Sec. 418.184. FIREARMS.

(a) A peace officer who is acting in the lawful execution of the officer’s official duties during a state of disaster may disarm an individual if the officer reasonably believes it is immediately necessary for the protection of the officer or another individual.

(b) The peace officer shall return a firearm and any ammunition to an individual disarmed under Subsection (a) before ceasing to detain the individual unless the officer:

(1) arrests the individual for engaging in criminal activity; or

(2) seizes the firearm as evidence in a criminal investigation.

To read Governor Abbott’s actual declaration, click here.
FLORIDA LAW ON FIREARMS CONFISCATION

Article IV, Section 1(a) of the Florida Constitution permits the Governor to issue an Executive Order to declare a State of Emergency in times of a natural disaster, allowing him to enact provisions of the State’s Emergency Management Plan.

For Hurricane Irma, the Executive Order provides specific provisions regarding the activities permissible to state and local officials during the emergency, as provided for in Florida Statutes beginning with Chapter 252.31 “State Emergency Management Act.”

In part, the Executive Order states:

Section 2. I designate the Director of the Division of Emergency Management as the State Coordinating Officer for the duration of this emergency and direct him to execute the State’s Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan and other response, recover, and mitigation plans necessary to cope with the emergency. Pursuant to section 252.36(1)(a), Florida Statutes, I delegate to the State Coordinating Officer the authority to exercise those powers delineated in sections 252.36(5)-(10), Florida Statutes, which he shall exercise as needed to meet this emergency, subject to the limitations of section 252.33, Florida Statutes.

But those powers have certain limitations with regards to firearms. In particular,

Chapter 252.36(5)(h) states the Governor may:

(h) Suspend or limit the sale, dispensing, or transportation of alcoholic beverages, firearms, explosives, and combustibles. However, nothing contained in ss. 252.31-252.90 shall be construed to authorize the seizure, taking, or confiscation of firearms that are lawfully possessed, unless a person is engaged in the commission of a criminal act.

FINAL WORD

So, there you have it. During our times of disaster, we can all focus on recovery and not have to worry about the authorities coming along and confiscating our firearms. The Second Amendment survives disasters.
Surprising Hurricane Harvey Heroes



[Addendum: Due inquiries from Members, this story was updated on Sept. 7.]

U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS CONFISCATING FIREARMS

On Tuesday, the island’s Governor ordered the National Guard to confiscate weapons and ammo that may be required for them to carry out their mission. What that specifically means is unclear. Also, the U.S. Virgin Islands IS NOT governed by the U.S. Constitution, but instead by the “Revised Organic Act of the Virgin Islands,” a federal law approved by Congress in 1954. The island does not have its own constitution yet.

The NRA has threatened to file a lawsuit, and here is their take:

In 1997, the chairman of the House Committee on Resources asked the General Accounting Office (GAO) to clarify just how the U.S. Constitutional applies to various “U.S. Insular Areas,” including the U.S. Virgin Islands. Its findings were inconclusive and unsettling, especially to those now living under Governor Mapp’s orders. Said the report:

Under the Insular Cases and subsequent decisions, rights other than fundamental rights, even though they may be stated in the Constitution, do not apply to the territories or possessions unless the Congress makes them applicable by legislation. The Congress can by law extend the coverage of the Constitution in part or in its entirety to a territory or possession, and has done so with respect to some territories. In the absence of such congressional action, however, only fundamental rights apply.

Digging further, one finds that only parts of the Fifth Amendment are considered to be “fundamental” based on court rulings, and none of the Sixth Amendment applies. And nothing is said in the 75-page report about the Second.

If the NRA does sue and their position is sustained by the courts that people living on the island are U.S. Citizens with full protection of the U.S. Constitution, the issue will be settled. If not, or no suit is filed, those living on the island will be subjected to having their weapons confiscated by the National Guard.

https://blog.uslawshield.com/can-gov...guns-disaster/

[allenr]

After reading post. # 78 above I noticed that the federal law applies only to federal authority not state or territorial. Therefore the VI governor was allowed to issue his order because the federal authorities or forces funded by the federal budget were not involved. The natioanl guard is Steve of territorial funded. Only when mobilized for federal duty does the federal government pay for their service.

[PAMedic=F|A=]

From what I've read, the U.S. Virgin islands are a territory and governed by a legal instrument called an Organic Act and not subject to the U.S. Constitution. Their version of a constitution is the 1954 Revised Organic Act of the Virgin Islands. It includes a bill of rights.. The Bill of Rights does NOT include an equivalent U.S. 2nd Amendment. There is a government restriction on search and seizure without due process, but this is apparently legally superseded by emergency EO. There were several attempts to draft an actual Constitution, the last being the Fifth Constitutional Convention in 2009 which was approved by the government of the USVI but must be ultimately approved by the US Congress where it failed for a variety of reasons (unrelated to any 2A issue).

Revised Organic Act of 1954...

https://www.doi.gov/sites/doi.gov/fi...icAct_1954.pdf


Fifth Constitutional Convention article

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_...Virgin_Islands

The addition of the 13th and 14th amendments, which they also include in the bill of rights means that prohibiting firearms is banned, because not having arms is the badge of a slave.