Revolver guys, Which one to carry?

[ray h]

If you had a choice between a new S&W Bodyguard 38 and a 40 year old S&W Model 60 38 with Crimson Trace laser grip, which one would you carry and why? Discuss.......

[AHelm3]

I'd probably go with the 60. When I was looking for a small revolver to carry, I fondled a Bodyguard and was not impressed at all.

Ended up going with an LCRx.

[R.A.D.]

i kinda chuckle at the laser warning... if you are pointing this at your eye, you have bigger problems than a low powered laser diode

[alpacaheat]

The metal one. That's always the right answer.

[eatmydust]

Assuming that they are equally reliable, I'd carry the BG .38 for two reasons.

1) It is going to be appreciably lighter and I find heavy CCWs a PITA.

2) I just looked up the price I paid for a Model 19 in 1998, I paid $249.99+tax & pics @ Targetmaster on 12/15/1998. That gun is pristine with box, paperwork and tools, it's worth roughly $1k. Older Smiths in good condition appreciate nicely over time.

[john9001]

J frame 442, hammerless for legal reasons.

[jthrelf]

a semi-auto 9..... jk

The Model 60 because I'd actually rather have more weight for controlled shooting and follow-ups.

[Sgt.K]

I am NOT a revolver guy (1911, .45ACP, TYVM). That said:

The Bodyguard *looks* like the grip permits a higher hand position relative to the bore axis. I know it's "just" a .38, but that could be a consideration for some.

My 2¢

[bigandy1966]

S&W M-38 airweight semi hammerless. Pre lock
No snag draws on the hammer
Alloy frame

[Maquis]

Top looks like my Model 60-7....almost everyday it's my go to though doubt you'll go wrong with either choice. Good belt and holster the weight is negligible.