Colt Navy Replica value?

[jaseman]

Have a Traditions 1851 Colt Navy replica that was given to me as a gift 15 or 20 years ago, and has been sitting in the closet since. As I'm trying to fund a future 1911 purchase, was wondering if anyone knew what the value on it should be before I try to sell or trade it in.

Specs:
Traditions - 1851 Colt Navy Brass replica
Black Powder "Cap & Ball" .44 cal
NIB condition - never fired

Any idea on what I should ask for it?

Believe this is the website for the gun.

Actual pics of mine:





Thanks

[knight0334]

They go for about $180 at Cabelas. Pre-owned though, I've seen them go for $75-$125. Yours though has the engraving on the cylinder - which should make it worth a little more.

I personally would put a price in the $100-$150 range for the condition that is in.

Trading in you might only get $50-$60 for it. Selling it will get you more money.

[drwho]

new at cabelas 179.00 on sale 139 used 75.00 to 125.00 colt never made a 1851 navy in brass or 44 caliber

[jaseman]

Thanks for the help guys. Gives me a starting point.

Any help with my rifle?

CVA Left-handed Flintlock