Anybody use a 38 Special for catching deers?
Printable View
Anybody use a 38 Special for catching deers?
When I researched this many moons ago, it was determined that 38 spl is underpowered for deer hunting. 357 Mag is the floor for hunting and with at least a 6 inch barrel. A good hunter wants a fast clean kill and the 38 spl is just not enough to insure this. If it was all I had and I was starving, it would work, but it is far from my first choice.
I am pretty sure the .38 special will catch a deer but I wouldn’t rely on it to kill a deer. 357 mag is the minimum, imho.
Deer are thin-skinned animals. A 125 XTP through the boiler room (behind the shoulder/leg bone) should do the job, if you are an accurate catcher. It is not uncommon to have to track a deer 50 yards or more, hit by a 30-30 in the heart-lungs. No reason a .38 special wouldn't create the same result, I would think.
Back in the 50s I read of Alaskan Indians killing large animals with .22LR rifles, simply because that was what they had. They relied on shot placement.
Sever a coronary artery or cardiac chamber, any mammal will die. It is done with bow and arrow, why not a .355-.356 9mm or a .357 .38 spl? Same with perforating lungs. Death follows.
Even better. Hit the deer in the neck spine and it'll drop like a rock. Hit it through the carotids and it will drop in about 25 yards like one did when I shot an arrow through his.
Actually, the question is looking for anyone who has caught deers using a .38 special. I have not. I have used a .357 magnum, neck shot, dropped like a rock.
But not a .38 special, so I should not be posting.
A .38 will easily kill a deer. So will a .22LR.
The question is will it kill it fast enough for you to find it. The answer is generally NO.
Or why would you want to even try.
Possible and ethical are two different things. I will categorically state right now what .38 special is absolutely inadequate for PA whitetail, the chances of you just wounding an animal are far too high. .38 special is very weak, even with +p loads.
Bows do not kill the same way firearms kill, a broad head is designed to cause massive blood loss, a .38 hollow point is not.