Does it work?
Such a simple idea to help re-center the barrel into the slide why haven't other manufactures incorporated it, or even aftermarket barrel makers?
pics for some views.....
http://www.pbase.com/1sfg/image/45891379/original.jpg
Printable View
Does it work?
Such a simple idea to help re-center the barrel into the slide why haven't other manufactures incorporated it, or even aftermarket barrel makers?
pics for some views.....
http://www.pbase.com/1sfg/image/45891379/original.jpg
I'm surprised... doesn't that o-ring wear out fairly quickly?
I would have guessed that the high speed friction of a semi-auto's recoil and general overall heat of bullet explosions would make that a poor engineering choice for o-rings.
Of course, I'm not a materials engineer, so what do I know?
I understand that it's no seal...
My puzzlement is over the fact that I would think the rubber material of the o-ring would wear away very quickly from the heat and friction and thereby not serve its intended purpose after a few dozen shots, if that.
Just out of curiosity, how many shots does that o-ring hold up for?
Based upon at least one "torture test" by Greg Bell over on HKPRO (on an HK45 full-size)... Over 10,000 rounds... Plus HK throws an extra 1 or 2 in the box... Now, as for how well it actually "works" in tightening lockup enough where one might notice greater accuracy... I don't think it makes much of a difference. But as long as it doesn't affect performance (which it doesn't), it can't hurt, IMO...
Regards,
-Bones
Yes, petroleum-based stuff does tend to damage rubber, from everything I've seen/read/etc. I think these O-rings are indeed some type of polymer/nylon derivative. I haven't contacted HK to ask them (not that you'd be able to get a definitive answer from their C.S anyhow), but this Greg Bell guy has a thread entitled "Project: Break My HK45." He's got pics to document all wear and tear that has occurred over the course of his "testing." He did the exact same thing with his P2000 a few years back, IIRC.
I had the same thought when I first saw this system: "It aint gonna last more than 500 rounds" (the O-ring that is). Apparently I was wrong...
Even before the Tacs and HK45 had it, I thougth the MK23/SOCOM had an O-ring system since it's introduction (But that is just based on my vague memories of handling one several years back; Very possible that I'm mistaken on that).
Regards,
-Bones
File this one under: Better living through science! :)Quote:
I think these O-rings are indeed some type of polymer/nylon derivative.
They don't seal anything, they just snug up the barrel to slide fit. You get a relatively consistent and tight lockup, without having to deal with match fitting... and the friction that comes with it.
It was some good forward thinking on HK's behalf... I'm not sure if it's patented, or not. HKPro would probably have an answer about that.
I can't help but notice that now TWO posters have mentioned "seal"...
I'm curious as to why this concept of sealing ever entered the discussion. :confused:
What am I missing here?