Quote:
Originally Posted by Siobhra
Freedom and responsibility are mutual and inseparable;
|
very true. if people are not held responsible for their actions and for providing for themselves, no one can be free.
i find this topic to be fascinating on a philosophical level, so i am going to comment on the points raised. my apologies to those of you who do not like such philosophical discussions, but no one is making you read this
i really think only the first two responsibilities on the list are actually needed. people must be responsible for their own actions and must respect the rights of others. that's pretty much all you need. if everyone really did that...i mean really do it, not just paying lip service to it...we could have a truly free society with little else in the way of laws, regulations, or obligations.
the third point, imho, is not required to have a free society. it is something decent, moral human beings strive to do anyway, but i don't think it is actually required to have a free society.
the fourth point is actually covered by the first point since taking responsibility for your own actions (or inactions) includes taking responsibility for providing for yourself (and your family).
the fifth point would be totally unnecessary...as laws would be totally unnecessary...if everyone actually followed the first two points.
the sixth point is covered by the second point, since respecting other people's rights includes respecting their property rights.
points 7, 8, and 9 are noble causes, and, given the realities of the world, are necessary to long-term survival of freedom. however, again, if everyone actually followed the first two points, these would be totally unnecessary.
point 10 is just a recap.
anyway, i guess my point is that it would be so ridiculously simple for us all to live in a free and peaceful world if all human beings would simply follow the first two points...take responsbility for your own actions and respect the rights of others. that's it...that's all that's required.
of course, as simple as that is, it will never happen. kind of a sad commentary on our species.