Thread: Defense gun.
View Single Post
  #2 (permalink)  
Old August 16th, 2007
dgg9 dgg9 is offline
Grand Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location:
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
(Philadelphia County)
Age: 50
Posts: 2,219
Rep Power: 46
dgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond reputedgg9 has a reputation beyond repute
Default Re: Defense gun.

Don't overpay for a pump shotgun. Mossberg 500/590 or Remington 870 (Police model preferable) will do the job.

The self defense shotgun's role is for close range, fast-acting encounters where the pace of events exceeds your ability to aim a standard rifle or handgun.

Given that, IMO rifle style sights are the wrong choice for a shotgun. There's no need. At the ranges we're talking -- 15 yards and in, often much closer -- front bead is 100% of what you need. Put bead on target, pull trigger. Ghost ring sights on a SG are like putting racing tires on a Model T.

Sidesaddle or butt cuff are nice in some contexts, but increase the complexity of the manual of arms, hence require more training and practice. Most home defense encounters can be settled with 5 rds of buckshot.

Pistol grip = unnecessary for most needs. Its benefits come from "tactical" considerations like being able to open/close doors while holding the gun one-handed. Again, making a big deal over a fringe issue. It does not really give better control -- your shoulder is doing the hard work, not your firing hand.

So:

Weapon-mounted light, extended mag tube = highly desirable.
Sidesaddle = nice to have.
Pistol grip, fancy sights = don't bother.

Pump shotgun is not hard to use BUT it's easy to short stroke under pressure, hence get training.
Reply With Quote